Catalonia must tread carefully as it seeks independence from Spain without crashing out of the EU

Goodbye Spain, Hello Europe?

, by Alistair Spearing

Goodbye Spain, Hello Europe?

A time traveller hopping from Barcelona in 2008 to the same city in 2013 could be forgiven for thinking his TARDIS had jumped a few decades into the future. Where Spanish flags once fluttered proudly to celebrate the country’s first win in the European Football Cup since 1964, a mosaic of defiant estelades (the pro-independence version of the Catalan flag) now brightly colours the balconies of Barcelona’s most important arteries. Where nationalist demonstrations once struggled to hit the 300,000 mark, now they easily smash through the 1.5 million barrier. And, most importantly, where barely a fifth of Catalans favoured independence, now support for it now consistently exceeds two thirds of those expressing an opinion in polls.

Equalisation payments from the wealthier to the poorer regions in Spain are significantly higher than in other countries of Western Europe, but the catalyst for the Catalan drive for independence is not the economy, at least not to a great extent. In fact, support for separatism started ticking upwards when Spain’s Constitutional Court significantly curtailed the powers laid down in a new Statute of Autonomy for Catalonia which had been approved by both the Catalan and the Spanish parliaments. Regardless of whether the Constitutional Court’s decision was right or wrong, it sparked outrage at what many perceived as yet another Madrid-based Spanish body riding roughshod over the democratic will of the Catalan people.

The victory of the Spanish People’s Party in the 2010 general election only added fuel to the fire. The centre- -right party saw the economic crisis as an opportunity to recentralise powers, something which obviously didn’t go down well in Catalonia and certain other autonomous regions. President Rajoy tried to sound conciliatory, but the damage was compounded by the words and actions of Education Minister Ignacio Wert, who pledged to “Hispanicise Catalan pupils” and drafted a law which would have relegated Catalan to the status of fourth educational language, behind not only Spanish but also English and a second foreign language. Many Catalans whose natural instinct would have been to oppose separation from Spain saw this as an all-out attack on their distinct cultural and linguistic identity and reluctantly shifted their stance. Wert’s plan backfired spectacularly as an otherwise moderate chunk of Catalan society was pushed into backing independence as a response to his adversarial tactics.

As it tries to ride the wave of public backing for independence and avoid being swept by it, the Catalan government has repeatedly gone out of its way to reassure everyone that Catalonia’s separatism is anything but isolationist. President Artur Mas himself has pledged his allegiance to European federalism by calling for a distinct Catalan state within a United States of Europe, where he suggests his nation could play the same role as Massachusetts in America (not that far-fetched, actually...). Despite a handful of dissonant voices here and there, Mas’ Convergence and Union party and its parliamentary allies have managed to present a mostly unified front when it comes to an independent Catalonia’s place in Europe.

As in Scotland’s case, there has been considerable discussion on whether an independent Catalonia would get to keep its place in the European Union. The Spanish Government says it would not, which was dismissed by EU officials, which were in turn refuted by higher EU officials, which were in turn overruled by even higher EU officials... The whole issue is about as clear as mud, and in all honesty it looks like it will only be resolved if Scotland and/or Catalonia vote for independence and a test case is brought before European courts. In any case, the Catalan Government has a Plan B that consists of joining EFTA as soon as possible following independence in order to dampen the economic shock of withdrawal and buy enough time for EU accession negotiations to proceed.

The other key question revolves around the currency of an independent Catalonia. While the political class is almost uniformly in favour of keeping the euro, the media and society are more or less evenly divided among those who think Catalonia would remain a full member of the Eurozone, those who believe it would fall out of the eurozone but be able to continue using the common currency à la Montenegro, and those who’ve been scalded by the euro crisis and would like Catalonia to print its own currency.

The Catalan independence process should not be seen as Catalonia turning its back on the world, Europe or even Spain itself. Indeed, while the short-term effects of a yes-to-independence vote would certainly be disruptive, in the mid-to-long term the Catalan society and political class see the nation firmly anchored to a federal Europe.

Granted, a year is a very long time in politics, so Catalans may very well end up getting cold feet and reluctantly vote to stay in Spain (although, unlike in Scotland, the pro-independence lead in opinion polls is the sort of margin that could realistically withstand a fierce and protracted referendum campaign). One thing, however, is for sure: come 2014, the eyes of Europe will be trained on this small corner of the north-west Mediterranean looking for its place in Spain, Europe and the world.

Your comments

  • On 19 January 2014 at 13:39, by Klaus Replying to: Goodbye Spain, Hello Europe?

    United States of Europe? Same role as Massachusetts? Is this serious?

  • On 25 May 2014 at 18:25, by Jose Replying to: Goodbye Spain, Hello Europe?

    Catalan and Spanish Nationalisms are both opposite to federalism.

    The article is a bit biased. Certainly the separatism has nothing to do with the unfortunate words and actions of Education Minister Ignacio Wert. It is a forgotten movement from the XIX century fueled now by certain politicians which blame the crisis to the central government, they want to increase their own power, and citizens are tired of suffering and want to believe that another reality is possible.

    The independence of catalonia (including south of france, alghero (IT), Valencian Community and the balearic islands, which non of them agree) responds to a plan orchestrated since the end of the Franco’s dictatorship and the regain of the democracy in the beginning on the 80’s.

    The perfect example is an elastic band. With Franco, only Spanish flag and language were allowed, and fake history was taugh. Today, after 30 years of the nationalist ruling in Catalonia, the situation during the dictatorship has been reversed: Spanish language is no longer being taugh at school, and children get indoctrinated in fake history as well.

    The reality today is that this movement is harming more than doing good. I am from the Valencian Community, speak proudly Catalan (called Valencian in my region) and I care about preserving our roots and identity. But fooling citizens into decimononic conceptions of never existing nations, creating borders were they are not, and putting brothers against each other is the oposit of my notion of federalism.

    It is not so easy as it may seem from ouside: powerful goliath is bad and people struggling for democracy. It is more about manipulation, deception and the confrontation of the Spanish Nationalism of Madrid against the Catalan Nationalism of Barcelona. None of them defending the Federalist approach.

Your comments


Warning, your message will only be displayed after it has been checked and approved.

Who are you?

To show your avatar with your message, register it first on (free et painless) and don’t forget to indicate your Email addresse here.

Enter your comment here

This form accepts SPIP shortcuts {{bold}} {italic} -*list [text->url] <quote> <code> and HTML code <q> <del> <ins>. To create paragraphs, just leave empty lines.

Follow the comments: RSS 2.0 | Atom