I recently had the opportunity to go travelling across southern Africa. While I travelled, I carried a long-held curiosity about the African Union with me. These travels were the ideal chance to ask ordinary people about this political entity that in my mind held so much promise. Is the AU anything like the EU? What does being an AU citizen give you? Does the AU inform your identity?
I asked these questions throughout my time. Informally and gingerly, of course. I know how sensitive the topic of continental unity can be, coming from Norway. Nonetheless, what emerged from these conversations was not an image of the AU as a controversial political entity like the EU. It seemed rather like a non-entity, little thought about, and even less respected. And that spoke volumes to me for how we think about unions, in Europe as well as abroad.
The AU consists of 55 member states on the African continent. Both in the amount of its member states and in its sheer population, it by far exceeds the EU. And its roots are almost as old. The AU began as the Organisation of African Unity all the way back in 1963 in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, the African country that was never colonised by Europeans. The Organisation of African Unity was ambitious from the very beginning. In fact, much more so than the EU’s humble origins in coal and steel.
The Ethiopian Emperor Haile Selassie hailed its inception as “the vision of an Africa not merely free but united”. Right out of the starting blocks, this political entity carried a beaming torch of African unity. In 2002, that torch passed to the AU as we know it today. Having stopped in Addis Ababa on my way south, I was curious about the progress of this mission. “Freedom” and “unity”: did these words carry any weight in people’s minds when they thought about the AU now? What did the citizens that make up this union think of its mission today?
Unions need to show respect to nations…
I grew up in a country where the topic of joining a continental union is divisive. It split the population down the middle in both EU referendums, with “no” having a slight majority in each. That means I am in the minority of EU supporters back home and felt the need to be gentle with my questions, slipping them into casual conversation, always being prepared to slip out should things go awry. That level of caution, however, was not necessary.
The people I asked responded more with a shrug than with a shudder. Instead of fiercely debating for or against the AU, they seemed to have dismissed it entirely. It was not a controversial political entity; it was a non-entity. To my surprise, I picked up little respect for the AU as a political player through my conversations with its citizens. But they were clear on why they did not respect the AU: no one seemed to.
Even more concerningly, they told me that the AU was consistently circumvented as a political player by states outside of Africa. Other countries preferred to strike deals with individual African states, and the states tended to follow suit. A dire image started to emerge in my mind of how the AU’s citizens thought about it. States outside the AU preferred to avoid it, states inside did not rally to it, and consequently people had little faith in it.
…but nations also need to show respect to unions
The AU seemed to suffer from a lack of respect on three fronts; from the outside, from the inside, and from the grassroots. This picture of harmlessness, or more, irrelevance, is something every union should fear. Back home, the EU has steered clear of this downward spiral. It demonstrates strong international leadership and commands respect among, at least, an important share of its citizens. And even its critics are at least not indifferent to it.
The fact that people all over Europe are passionately debating the future of this project and what unity should look like, confirms that most people believe the EU wields genuine political power both domestically and internationally. They may not like what the union does, but they do believe the union can do something. That is a quite different picture than the one I got of the AU.
The EU has invested time and effort in being able to act as one on the international stage. As such, it has succeeded in commanding respect on all three points; from the outside, the inside, and from the grassroots. These three points, however, are constant pitfalls. Southern Africa taught me that if respect starts to bleed in one area, the union itself loses vitality.
European federalism must promote global federalism
So, how can we safeguard respect for a continental union? We can actively encourage others. I left southern Africa with a strong feeling that the EU and the AU should prop each other up. As calls for a federal Europe become more tenacious, federalist thinking should permeate foreign policy too. How can Europe speak credibly as a union, if divide-and-rule is the language used abroad? How can we command respect for that federation, if we do not show respect for other federalist attempts?
Any federalist project should be international in scope, and building unions at home should entail actively encouraging them abroad. The horror of losing respect on the three fronts outlined above is that it is almost impossible to know where the drain begins. Is it the lack of external respect that sets the downward spiral in motion? Is it insufficient devotion by its constituent states? Or is apathy among citizens the first domino to fall?
The horror is that it is all interconnected and the demise can begin anywhere. The beauty of this interconnectedness, however, is that we can start building respect on any of these points with reverberating effects. If the EU actively props up the AU as a political player, then that is one sizable union that respects the EU in return. By looking to other unions when we conduct foreign policy, we direct the attention of individual states towards them.
Where national leaders look, the populace is sure to follow. Unions of nations should command respect by showing it to other unions of nations. That respect trickles down to the grassroots. And the respect won there is the bedrock of any federation. The EU and AU, together, can show that federalism can work globally. Yet, they are also capable of showing that they cannot. How future citizens will talk about them will depend on our actions today.

Follow the comments:
|
